|
▼すればいいのにさん:
>ヘイト スピーチが言論の自由で守られているのなら、なんで白人 至上主義者にきっちり教育してあげないんでしょう?白人が低学歴すぎて、それを理解できないからですかね?
トピが変な方向に一人歩きしているようなので、著名な憲法学者の「Gerald Gunther」を言葉をどうぞ。
The proper answer to bad speech is usually more and better
speech—not new laws, litigation, and repression. . . .
I received my elementary education in a public school in a very
small town in Nazi Germany. There I was subjected to vehement antiSemitic
remarks from my teacher, classmates and others. . . . I can
assure you that they hurt. More generally, I lived in a country where
ideological orthodoxy reigned and where the opportunity for dissent
was severely limited.
The lesson I have drawn from my childhood in Nazi Germany
and my happier adult life in this country is the need to walk the sometimes
difficult path of denouncing the bigot’s hateful ideas with all my
power, yet at the same time challenging any community’s attempt to
suppress hateful ideas by force of law.
Obviously, given my own experience, I do not quarrel with the
claim that words can do harm.
Gunther famously defended the freedom of speech rights of American Nazis.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Gunther
基本、ヘイトスピーチをする人に、ヘイトスピーチで返してヘイトを経験させても、ヘイトスピーチをする人にヘイトを理解させる、教育することなんて無理なんですよ。理解できないから、ヘイトスピーチをするのだから。
唯一の有効な対抗手段は、「more and better speech」だと思いますよ。
このトピの一部やりとりを見ても明らかなようにー。
|
|
|